Anthony Rapp (left) and Kevin Spacey.Photo: Dia Dipasupil/Getty; Jason Merritt/Getty

Anthony Rapp, Kevin Spacey

During cross-examination at the civil trial in Manhattan, defense attorney Jennifer Keller questioned Rapp’s account of his first meeting with Spacey in 1986, which differed from the deposition of a friend, who was present at the time, according to theAssociated Press.

After taking the stand, Rapp, 50, recalled how when he was 14, Spacey allegedly asked him and his older friend to join him at a nightclub after the trio met backstage at Spacey’s Broadway show. He testified that they left the nightclub and returned home without incident, per the AP.

But the unidentified friend — who was a teen at the time — reportedly claimed in a deposition that they went to Spacey’s home the first night they met, where the Oscar winner attempted to entice Rapp into a sexual encounter.

According to the AP, Keller asked Rapp in court, “Considering the friend’s deposition, ‘You knew you had a problem with your story, correct?'” In response, Rapp said on the stand, “I don’t dispute his story. I just don’t remember it.”

Kevin Spacey arrived at NY court.ANGELA WEISS/AFP via Getty Images

Kevin Spacey arrives to attend a civil trial hearing on sexual abuse charges brought against him by Anthony Rapp in Manhattan federal court

Rapp also testified in court that he told a classmate about his sexual encounter with Spacey, alleging that he was watching television in a bedroom when Spacey “came in drunk, picked me up as a groom does a bride, and he climbed on top of me trying to get with me sexually and I managed to squirm away,” per the AP.

During the cross-examination, theRentactor clarified that Spacey never attempted to touch his genitals, remove his clothing or make any references to sex. He also denied having any sort of crush or obsession with Spacey.

Rapp did, however, recall feeling “stuck with a cattle prod” after going to see a movie starring Spacey in high school, and testified that he ran into Spacey in the bathroom at the 1999 Tony Awards.

“As I was washing my hands, Kevin Spacey walked through the door. I looked at him and he looked at me. That was startling. … I wanted very much to get away,” Rapp said, per the AP.

Rapp is expected to continue testifying Wednesday, according to the outlet.

Kevin Spacey.ANGELA WEISS/AFP via Getty Images

Kevin Spacey arrives to attend a civil trial hearing on sexual abuse charges brought against him by Anthony Rapp in Manhattan federal court

Jury selection begun on Thursdayin connection to the alleged incident involving Spacey and Rapp.

Rapp first accused Spacey of sexual misconduct inan October 2017BuzzFeed report, which was published 31 years after the alleged incident. The Broadway actor is seeking $40 million in compensatory and punitive damages for battery and intentional infliction of emotional distress, according toReuters.

In the wake of the Rapp allegations, Spacey became subject toseveral other sexual misconduct cases, including a2018 lawsuitinvolving the alleged rape of a young man.

In May, Spacey was charged with sexually assaulting three men in the U.K. Hepleaded not guilty to the chargesin July. He also pleaded not guilty to one charge of making a person engage in penetrative sexual activity without consent.

RELATED VIDEO: Kevin Spacey Pleads ‘Not Guilty’ to Sexual Assault Charges in London Court

Despite the allegations against him, director Franco Nero confirmed toVarietyin May that he had cast Spacey as a police detective inL’uomo Che Disegnò Dio.

The actor was also set to appear inPeter Five Eight, but producers of the film confirmed in May that he dropped out upon being charged with the four counts of sexual assault. (Hebacked out of1242: Gateway to the Westas well.)

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up to date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

While Spacey’s court date is underway in New York,his U.K. trialis set to commence some time next year.

If you or someone you know has been sexually assaulted, please contact the National Sexual Assault Hotline at 1-800-656-HOPE (4673) or go torainn.org.

source: people.com